2 HOME NEWS
DECEMBER 2 2011 THE CATHOLIC HERALD
FFolllooww Thhee CCatholicc Heerald oonn Twwitttteer At Twitter.com/catholicherald
MP takes on Government over same-sex regulations
BY MADELEINE TEAHAN
A CATHOLIC MP is resisting Government plans to push through a measure permitting same-sex civil ceremonies on religious premises without formal debate or scrutiny in the House of Commons.
Edward Leigh MP is seeking to prevent regulations from coming into force which lift the ban on hosting civil ceremonies on religious premises. The removal of the ban was approved in the House of Lords last year.
Lord Alli tabled an amendment to the Equality Act in March 2010 to lift the ban after some Jewish and Quaker communities voiced their support for the change in the law.
But concern has been raised among some religious groups, peers and MPs that permitting civil ceremonies on religious premises will prompt legal action against priests or ministers who refuse to register civil partnerships.
The legislative procedures used by the Government to ratify this change have provoked particular disquiet as it would exclude debate in the House of Commons.
Edward Leigh has tabled an Early Day Motion to annul the new regulations. He said: “These regulations don’t do what the Government promised which is to protect churches that do not want to register civil partnerships. It is an issue of the utmost seriousness. Yet the Commons currently isn’t even being given a chance to debate them.
“We’ve seen all this before. The Sexual Orientation Regulations went through Parliament without proper scrutiny and they closed down our adoptions agencies as a result. If the Government cares anything about the churches, it will withdraw these regulations and think again.”
If Mr Leigh’s motion galvanises the Government, a committee will be formed of approximately 30 MPs who will revisit the regulations and put their conclusions to the House of Commons.
If members object to the committee’s findings, then the regulations will be voted on by MPs but without debate on the floor of the House. But this pause in the regulations’ legislative passage is down to the discretion of the Government.
Although the situation is still uncertain in the House of Commons, Baroness O’Cathain has secured a debate for December 15 in the House of Lords which seeks to annul the regulations that will lift the current ban. Members of the house have traditionally been allowed a free vote on this issue as a matter of conscience.
Christian lobbyists are particularly concerned that Parliament re-examines Lord Alli’s amendment because they say it did not receive sufficient parliamentary scrutiny or support at the time of its passage.
Simon Calvert, spokesman for the Christian Institute, said: “The Government has chosen to legislate in a way that allows no scrutiny in the Commons, and very little in the Lords. There is no opportunity to amend the regulations. Peers concerned for religious freedom have no option but to try to vote them down. We must hope they succeed.
“The original amendment which gave rise to the regulations was passed in irregular circumstances. Only 95 peers voted for it, and 21 against. The Labour government pulled a surprise late night vote when only supporters of the amendment were still present. They listed a series of major flaws with the amendment, but declined to vote it down. It was reckless.
“The Coalition Government is reinforcing the error with these regulations.”
Neil Addison of the Thomas More Legal Centre said that on the surface the regulations to lift the ban on civil ceremonies on religious premises were innocuous.
But, he said that the use of the Equality Act by local authorities could result in them refusing to register churches for marriage unless they perform civil ceremonies.
He said: “As they are drafted the regulations deal with concerns because they are very clear that no religious organisation will be obliged to host civil partnerships.
“The problem is that in all areas of law these days you can’t just look at these regulations in isolation because the Equality Act and the Human Rights Act will affect them.
“The real danger is the possibility of churches being sued under the Equality Act for refusing to host civil partnerships.
“But what I think is much more likely is that local authorities will refuse to register churches for marriage unless the churches are willing to host civil partnerships. This will affect Catholic churches, synagogues, and many other denominations.”
He said that in future years registration of Catholic marriages may take place outside of Mass.
Ken Russell, pictured in 1992, said the Virgin Mary helped him to overcome an addiction to snuff AP
Convert Ken Russell mourned BY MADELEINE TEAHAN
THE FILMMAKER and Catholic convert Ken Russell has died at the age of 84.
Friends and family said that he had died in hospital on Sunday following a series of strokes.
The filmmaker’s son, VerneyElliot, said: “My father died peacefully. He had a series of strokes. He died with a smile on his face.” His wife Elize said that she was “devastated” and that her husband’s death was “completely unexpected”.
The convert was most famous for his controversial films Women in Love and The Devils.
Glenda Jackson, who won an Oscar for her role in Women in Love, said it had been a privilege to be his friend. She said: “He was absolutely wonderful to work with. He welcomed ideas from other people, from the clapper boy all the way up. But the final choice was always his. He created the kind of climate in which actors could do their job and I loved him dearly.
“Visually he was just extraordinary. It was as if he had a third eye. And he managed to transmit that third eye, which was always rooted in his own passionate sense of justice, on to the screen.
“Whenever I think of him I tend to smile and the sense of excitement of working for him and the camera is still palpable. It was a great privilege to work with him and it was an even greater privilege to regard him and be regarded by him as a friend.”
Ken Russell converted to Catholicism because, according to one friend, he “saw the world as a Romantic Catholic does – full of mystery and magic”.
In an interview with The Catholic Herald in 1999, he said that his interest in Catholicism was sparked when a newly converted housemate told him that Catholics “eat God”.
He said: “That totally freaked me out. I said ‘You’re crazy’ and he told me about the Last Supper and the whole lot. He convinced me it was true. I went for instruction and expected to go to Farm Street. But I was sent to Poor Clares off Portobello Road.
“I was there for six months talking to a 17-year-old novice. At the end of that, she said: ‘I think you are as ready as you’re ever going to be.’”
He said in the interview that he did not go to church but that he found God in the countryside and during long walks in the woods. He said: “The forest is part of God, a part a lot of people ignore. I’m very conscious of God when I live in the country; less so when I live in the town.”
Russell had a strong devotion to Our Lady who he claimed helped him to overcome an addiction to snuff while travelling on the number 19.
“I had a terrible addiction to snuff. I’d shake and I had to have it every 10 minutes. My eyes would stream. I felt I couldn’t think unless I had a pinch of snuff. I was very hard up at the time but I bought this statue of the Madonna and I had it on the bus.
“I had this tin of snuff with me and I couldn’t lever it open. I didn’t have a coin so I thought I’d ask the conductor to change a note. He came along and said: ‘I’ve got not change mate, forget it.’ The bus was rocking and I was having to hold her... I said: ‘For heaven’s sake, can’t you stop me taking this awful stuff?’
“I got off the bus. I put her on the mantle piece and I never touched the stuff again.” Editorial Comment: Page 13
Traditional and Modern Bibles, Missals, Catechism, Prayer, Childrens Books, Christmas Nativity Sets
Catholic Books & Gifts
Statues, Rosaries, Medals,
Crucifixes, Icons, DVDs,
Candles, Incense www.cenacle.co.uk
Tel: 01695 558603
Holy Mass December 11th at 10.45am
St. Bede’s Catholic Church 58 Thornton Road, London SW12 0LF Mass in honour of Our Lady of Loreto by Vinzenz Goller
Director Charles Finch 020 8648 8852 or 078 8617 6227
ADVERTISING TERMS AND CONDITIONS Advertisements submitted must contain complete and accurate information, comply with requirements of all relevant legislation and the British Code of Advertising Practice and the Advertising Standards Authority. The publisher has the right, at its discretion, to refuse, omit, suspend, or change the position of advertisements, or require artwork or copy to be amended to comply with any moral or legal obligations. The publisher will not be liable for any loss of revenue to the advertiser incurred as a consequence of non publication or incorrect reproduction of an advertisement or failure to insert a loose leaf insert. Advertisements may be cancelled within 14 days of an order being received and not less than a minimum of 24 hours before deadline for entry. Any cancellations outside this period will not affect the buyer’s liability for payment for the advertisement. Payment for advertisements must be received within 30 days. Any order (verbal or written) which is placed for the insertion of an advertisement amounts to an acceptance of these conditions.
THE CATHOLIC HERALD 15 Lamb’s Passage Bunhill Row London EC1Y 8TQ
College: abortion counselling must not be mandatory Education agency offers guide to opposing bus cuts
BY MADELEINE TEAHAN
THE ROYAL COLLEGE of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG) has said that women who are sure that they want an abortion should “not be subjected to compulsory counselling”.
In its latest guidelines concerning abortion, the Royal College said that counselling should be available for women who want it but it should not be a mandatory part of the process in accessing an abortion.
The new guidelines state: “Women who are certain of their decision to have an abortion should not be subjected to compulsory counselling.
“Pathways to additional support, including counselling and social services, should be available.”
The timing of the guidelines is politically significant as the Government has scheduled a consultation on the current state of counselling services for women facing crisis pregnancies.
The issue of abortion counselling has become increasingly politicised since an amendment to the Health and Social Care Bill was defeated in September.
The amendment was tabled by Nadine Dorries, Conservative MP for mid-Bedfordshire,who tried to strip abortion providers of their role in pregnancy counselling because they have a financial interest in women having an abortion.
John Smeaton, the director of the Society for the Protection of Unborn Children, described the new guidelines as “bad science” which were rooted in ideology. He said: “The RCOG’s new guideline further entrenches its de facto role as the puppet of the abortion industry. Whether it is the physical and psychological effects of abortion, conscientious objection or counselling for women, the RCOG promotes ideology and bad science instead of high clinical and ethical standards.
“The RCOG says that counselling should be merely ‘offered on request’. The new guideline doesn’t even cover counselling in detail. The guideline does, however, give the paltry assurance that ‘[w]omen should be informed that they have a right to delay or cancel appointments and/or the [abortion] should they wish’.
“The RCOG is particularly keen to get women to use contraception even though contraception is closely associated with rising abortion figures.
Mr Smeaton said: “Chillingly, the guideline recommends that in some case ‘feticide should be performed... to ensure that there is no risk of a live birth.’ That is the reality of abortion: the killing of babies, denied their equal right to life.”
BY ED WEST
THE CATHOLIC Education Service of England and Wales (CESEW) has intensified its campaign against cuts to transport subsidies for Catholic schools with a new “transport toolkit”.
The guide gives teachers, governors, parents and diocesan officials information behind local authority cuts and advice on how to campaign against them and to gain media coverage.
Traditionally local authorities have subsidised school transport for religious schools, which tended to attract pupils from a wide geographic area, and the cost can be up to £1,379 per year per pupil. In other cases local authorities have removed bus routes that stop at Catholic schools.
The CESEW argues that local authorities have unfairly discriminated against religious schools and that cuts hit the most in need. They also argue that by cutting the subsidies of children already in secondary school, or already allocated a place, they are leaving parents with huge transport costs that may have influenced their decision to send their child to that school.
They also point out that central government has always supported the principle of subsidised transport, and that the cuts only bring minimal benefits to local authorities anyway. Those involved with the campaign are also advised about the legal duty. Assistance with travel costs to religious schools was enshrined in the 1944 Education Act, and the 1996 Education Act places “a duty on local authorities to ensure suitable travel arrangements are made to facilitate a child’s attendance at school”.
It also advises parents, teachers and governors to write to local authority officials, local councilors, MPs and the Local Government Ombudsman, and consider pursuing a judicial review into local decision-making, gives advice on writing press releases to local newspapers, and to making use of social media.
Middlesbrough diocese has meanwhile criticises plans by a local council to cut free transport for church school pupils as an attack on “human rights”.
Middlesbrough Council has begun a consultation over plans to cut the service, which it said would save £350,000 over six years, part of plans to save £38 million. The council spends £100,000 a year providing transport to 385 pupils and 12 schools – all Catholics that would be affected by the plans.
Councils in Wakefield, West Yorkshire and Hartlepool are also consulting on scrapping bus subdsidies.
NEWSBULLETIN For one week all donations to the Passage are doubled EVERY pound given to the Catholic homeless charity The Passage next week will net the company £2, after it signed up to the Big Give, a scheme which doubles donations given to charities.
fundraising scheme, established by employment agency Reed. For donations that are gift aided, the Passage gains another 25p per £1.
Any donation given from Monday to Friday next week will give the charity, founded in 1980 by Cardinal Basil Hume, a matched amount from the
The Passage recently received a £500,000 cut in funding. Chief executive Mick Clarke said: “Our residential projects help... break the cycle of homelessness.” For more information visit Passage.org.uk
Sixty Anglicans to become Catholic SIXTY Anglicans in Darlington are to be received into the Catholic Church at Easter next year.
The group, of St James the Great Anglican church, is expected to be one of the biggest groups of the Personal Ordinariate of Our Lady of Walsingham.
The Rt Rev Justin Welby, the Anglican Bishop of Durham, has said that he will preach at their group’s final service in February.
The bishop told the Northern Echo that the departure of the Rev Ian Grieves, who is preparing to join the ordinariate, would be a “loss to the diocese”.
He said: “I have known Ian Grieves for a long time. When I was training, in 1992, I did a placement with him at St James and I learnt a huge amount from him. He’s a very good priest.”
Mr Grieves had been parish priest at St James for 22 years, according to the Northern Echo.
CESEW praises Bible initiative THE CATHOLIC Education Service of England and Wales (CESEW) has welcomed the Government’s announcement that it is sending a King James Bible to every school in England.
A spokesman for the CESEW said it was “excellent news” that the Bible would be made available to all children. The initiative is intended to mark the 400th anniversary of the Bible’s publication.
Bishop rests after operation BISHOP Crispian Hollis of Portsmouth, who was diagnosed with bowel cancer in June, has said he has received the last of his treatment and is recovering at Bishop’s House. He said: “Once again, I want to say that I don’t think I could have come through the traumas of the last three months without your constant love, care and prayers, so please know how grateful I am.”
Bishop resigns on health grounds POPE BENEDICT XVI has accepted the resignation of Bishop Seamus Hegarty of Derry, Northern Ireland, on health grounds. More than a quarter of Ireland’s 26 dioceses are now awaiting a new bishop.
A S S
ME DJUG O RJE
I A G O
S A NT
K RA K O W
HO LY LA ND
I E UX
LLO URDE S
Tangney Tours Flights to Lourdes lights to Lourdes
Special promotion! Book a full package tour for travel to
Lourdes in 2012, quote reference: PROMO2011 and you will receive a free travel bag and lanyard!*
2012 Brochure Our new brochure is now with us,
Please contact us for your
FREE copy. Returning for 2012 - Flights direct to Lourdes with the full service included and no extras!
Christmas in Lourdes hristmas in Lourdes
Book now for the 8th of December in Lourdes, Feast of the Immaculate Conception from £250
Christmas in Lourdes We only have limited places, so Please contact us for free on 0800 9173572
Book now for February in Lourdes by luxury coach,
from £299 per person, 8 - 12 February
First flights for Easter begin on 6th of April We are also taking bookings for groups for 2012 including free places! Contact us now for details.
Holy Land 2012 Holy Land 2012
Pilgrimage from Manchester
A S S
ME DJUG O RJE
I A G O
S A NT
K RA K O W
13th - 20th February Led by Fr Michael McCoy
Jerusalem, Bethlehem, Nazareth, Nablus, Jericho Sea of Galilee and more!
If the above dates are unsuitable, please contact us as you may be able to join one of our other groups, or why not lead a group yourself?
HO LY LA ND
The Oﬃcial Catenian
Pilgrimage 2012 19th - 29th March 11 Days - full board Contactusforafreebrochure
20122012 Marcch boaoaoaoardrdrdrd ebrbrbrbrochochocochureu
Join us on facebook:
I E UX
LLO URDE S
www.tangney-tours.com e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org FREE BROCHURE LINE: 0800 917 3572 THE CATHOLIC HERALD DECEMBER 2 2011
BBeeccoommee aa ffaann ooff TThhee CCaatthhoolliicc HHeerraalldd At Facebook.com
Holocaust teaches vigilance, says Bishop Davies BY ED WEST
THE NAZI murder of six million Jews should serve as a warning to Christians today to remain vigilant against threats to human life, Bishop Mark Davies of Shrewsbury has said at a service marking the Holocaust.
Speaking at a synagogue in Manchester, Bishop Davies said that Christians cannot fail to recognise that Hitler’s campaign of annihilation was directed against a people chosen by God Himself, who Pope Benedict XVI has called “our fathers” in faith.
In a warning against the increasing acceptance of assisted suicide, he said that such thinking continued today in eugenic beliefs about the unborn and the sick.
Giving an address on the significance of the Holocaust to Christians, he quoted
Blessed Pope John Paul II’s words that “no one is permitted to pass by the tragedy of the Shoah”.
Bishop Davies said: “Four years ago I travelled with a group of Catholic priests to Auschwitz-Birkenau and my abiding memory will be of the silence which marked that day and continued in the group long into the evening.”
It is “a silence which becomes, in Pope Benedict’s words, a heartfelt cry to God which leads us to bow our heads before the endless number who suffered and were put to death and a plea to the living God that this must never happen again.
“We are painfully conscious that mass crimes, acts of genocide and cruelty on an unimaginable scale have continued to disfigure history.
“We think of the trial continuing today of the former rulers of Cambodia and we cannot forget the return of ‘eugenic’
thinking directed against the unborn and the most vulnerable deemed ‘unfit to live’ or threatened with ‘mercy killing’.
He added: “The struggle against evil continues.”
The bishop was invited by the Menorah synagogue in south Manchester to speak at a Holocaust Study Day, along with Dr Edward Kessler, director of the Woolf Institute, Cambridge, Holocaust survivor Doris Angel, Canon Albert Radcliffe and Prof Ilana Crome, academic director of psychiatry at Keele University.
Bishop Davies also quoted Pope John Paul II’s speech at Auschwitz in 1979 when the Polish pontiff said: “For the death camps were built for the negation of faith – faith in God and faith in man – to trample radically not only on love but on all signs of human dignity, of humanity. A place built on hatred and contempt for man.” The late pope grew up in Wadowice, only a few miles from the site of the camp, and had many Jewish friends as a child, part of a community that was wiped out in just five years.
Bishop Davies said that: “As Christians we cannot fail to see that amidst all the victims of Nazism it was a chosen people who were marked down for systematic and total destruction.
“The Nazi reign of terror we recall today was based on a racist myth on an idolatry of race and state but as both Pope John Paul II and Pope Benedict XVI have reminded us, it was also a radical rejection of the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob who is, ‘the God of Jesus Christ and all who believe in him’. For ‘the almighty’ Hitler and the Nazis spoke of was a pagan idol as Pope Benedict declared in Berlin’s Reichstag building in September this year. This idol, Pope
Benedict said, ‘wanted to take the place of the biblical God, the Father and Creator of all men’.
“And contemporary historians point to the logical intention of the National Socialist state rooted in this idolatry of man, of race, of the state to destroy not only the Jewish race but Christian morality and the faith of the Church.”
He added that both Jews and Christians saw that the Holocaust trampled on the Ten Commandments “in a systematic eradication of morality”.
He concluded: “The study of the Holocaust must lead to a deeper appreciation of the close bonds between the Jewish people and Christians recognising our common roots and the rich spiritual patrimony we share. An ideology which grew at the centre of European civilisation sought to remove from the face of the earth in this Holocaust the people called by the Lord before all others. This must surely lead us to recognise every continuing assault upon the value and dignity of every human life and person and to recognise in this the denial of the Creator. This must call us to vigilance in the face of the developing ideologies and mindsets of our time so often hostile to the JudeoChristian foundations on which our civilisation was built.”
The bishop has become one of the leading critics of the loss of respect for life in British society and culture.
In October he criticised the treatment of the elderly in British hospitals, saying that “the neglect of the elderly on National Health Service hospital wards may be a symptom of the ‘culture of death’ that has grown out the loss of respect for human life following decades of abortion and destructive experimentation on human embryos”.
Baroness leads effort to rescue Pugin gem
BY STAFF REPORTER
BARONESS D’SOUZA and ITN newsreader Alastair Stewart have helped to launch a campaign to save St Augustine’s church in Ramsgate, Kent, at the House of Lords.
The parish priest, Fr Marcus Holden, is aiming to raise £1 million over four years to repair the church, which was designed and built by A W Pugin in the 1840s.
Fr Holden, who became parish priest last year, said: “It is significant at so many levels: spiritually it’s the monument of St Augustine’s landing, historically it’s a centre piece of the 19thcentury Catholic revival, and architecturally it’s Pugin’s masterpiece.”
St Augustine’s in Ramsgate, Kent, was regarded by its architect A W Pugin as his ideal church and is thought to be located near to where St Augustine landed in AD 597
Government orders RTÉ inquiry Petition handed in over sex education
BY ED WEST
IRELAND’S national broadcaster has suspended a flagship television programme after it defamed a priest.
RTÉ suspended Prime Time Investigates after the government ordered an independent inquiry into why the show falsely accused Fr Kevin Reynolds of rape.
RTÉ is believed to have paid out more than €1m (£860,000) to Fr Kevin Reynolds in a libel action last month after falsely accusing him of rape and fathering a child while he was a missionary in Kenya. Some 500,000 people saw the episode and the allegation was repeated on national radio the following morning.
Before the programme was broadcast Fr Reynolds had offered to take a paternity test, but the programme makers went ahead. He later took the test, which proved negative.
The broadcaster has launched an internal inquiry into the conduct of the programme makers, although it has said that no dismissals would follow as a result of the failings. Fr Sean McDonagh, spokesman for the Association of Catholic Priests, welcomed the announcement of the investigation and said it would be an opportunity to review the perceived anti-Catholic bias within RTÉ and the Irish media in general. Communications minister Pat Rabbitte said the Reynolds case was considered at a Cabinet meeting.
BY ED WEST
A GROUP of parents were due to meet in London yesterday to express anger over the way that primary school children are being exposed to sexually explicit material in schools.
The Safe at School campaign, established by the Society for the Protection of Unborn Children, organised the meeting to protest at videos, such as “Living and Growing”, which show graphic sexual images as part of sex education classes.
Afterwards the group will present a 47,000-strong petition to Education Secretary Michael Gove calling on him to ban explicit videos from British primary schools.
Among the speakers at the meeting, called “Sex education as sexual sabotage” and organised alongside the Working Party on the Sexualisation of Children under the Lords and Commons Family and Child Protection Group, are Lynette Burrows, a,uthor of Fight for the Family and Dr Judith Reisman, an expert on Alfred Kinsey and the origins of sex education programmes.
Antonia Tully, co-ordinator of the Safe at Schools Campaign, said: “The government need to deal with the problem of materials being introduced into schools by local councils. This is what we’re hearing from parents all over the country. We’re saying wake up, this type of pornographic material is being used, and parents are unhappy.”
t One W Jus orld t One W t One World t One W Jus
Just One World orld t One W t One World orld orld
Nearly fi y years ago we began our journey together working b e drinking w f o sa s t esc ac But in developing c s and sist thero br e ar ther w ego And t o eliminat t s ag ear Nearly fi y y to eliminate poverty and injustice. And together we are helping to save lives and support our e their fi h birthday. ef er and one in every t at e drinking w eople don’t have on p 4 milli , 88 es ri ount But in developing c o mak orld t ound the w s ar er o save lives and supp e helping t e ar c verty and injusti o e p o eliminat o y t an our journe eg e b o w brothers and sisters around the world to make a living. But in developing countries, 884 million people don’t have access to safe drinking water and one in every ten children dies er and one in every t eople don’t have e a living. o mak ort our o save lives and supp e.c orking ther w ego es en di en childr before their fi h birthday.
the justio d t ar orw o f e g as w si as omp e, c our hop y er than our r eat The need is gr efb f Go dom o f the king e o c the justi orld that t o build a w ther t eg e mor darity ar on and soli si an mee es c c esour er than our r e their fi h birthday. or ef
The need is greater than our resources can meet. That’s why your hope, compassion and solidarity are more vital than ever as we go forward together to build a world that truly reflects d. f Go eflects ruly r orld that t al than ever e vit e mor t. That’s why an mee the justice of the kingdom of God.
Snyd e r/C RS
: D av id
P ho tography
C harit y
C harit y e d iste re d e r ist e g
Cruise ship hires non-Catholic to celebrate Mass BY ED WEST
UP TO 20 cruise ship passengers have expressed concern after a man believed by the cruise company to be a Catholic priest was hired to celebrate Mass despite not being in communion with the Pope.
Passengers on the Queen Mary 2 travelling from New York to Southampton last week were told that “Catholic Mass” would be celebrated on board, only to find that the celebrant belonged to a denomination called the American Old Catholic Church, which denies the authority of the Pope as well as Church teaching on birth control, divorce and a number of other issues.
The group has 12 parishes across the western United States and traces its succession to the Old Catholic Church of Utrecht, the Dutch Jansenist group of the late 17th century.
The cruise liner appears to have booked Archbishop Michael Senco without realising that he was not in communion with Rome.
In a letter to Cunard Line, which runs the ship, British passenger Nicholas Bennett wrote: “Any ‘Mass’ conducted by this celebrant would be null and void and the communion would be invalid.”
Mr Bennett, a former Conservative MP and minister and a member of the Catholic Union, arrived at the first Mass where he told the group of guests waiting that it was not an authentic Catholic Mass. Mr Bennett said an official appeared and warned him that he would be removed by security if he stood outside the service.
Mr Bennett was told that as the service was not advertised as a “Roman Catholic Mass” there was no room for confusion. But he argued “that Catholics would rightly assume that a service described as a ‘Catholic Mass’ would be performed by a Roman Catholic priest”.
“The chances of anybody assuming that a ‘Catholic Mass’ would refer to a Mass celebrated by a non-RC priest belonging to an obscure and schismatic church were infinitesimal,” he wrote.
Speaking to The Catholic Herald, Mr Bennett said: “I’m astonished that a company worth billions of pounds can make such an error.”
He said that he collected the email addresses of 20 other passengers who had expressed concern about the mix-up and wanted to be kept informed. Eventually, he said, a member of staff investigated the matter and apologised for the error.
By coincidence retired Bishop James Timlin of Scranton, Pennsylvania, happened to be on the ship on his way to his ad limina visit in Rome, and he agreed to celebrate Mass each day.
Neither Cunard Line nor Archbishop Senco were available for comment.