Prospec

ISSUE 132 MARCH 2007

contents

CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS ISSUE

PHILIP BALL ’s most recent book is The Devil’s Doctor (Heinemann) PETER BAZALGETTE is chairman of Endemol DAVID CLARK was special adviser to Robin Cook at the foreign office,1997-2001 MARK COUSINS is the author of The Story of Film (Pavilion Books) JASON COWLEY is a senior editor at the Observer ALEX DE WAAL is a director at the Social Science Research Council MARGARET DRABBLE ’s most recent novel is The Sea Lady (Fig Tree) RONALD DWORKIN is a professor of law and philosophy at New York University TERRY EAGLETON is professor of cultural theory at the University of Manchester CHARLES GRANT is director of the Centre for European Reform CHRISTOPHER HIRD is joint managing director of Fulcrum Productions JIM HOLT writes for the NYTMagazine JOHN KAY is the author of The Truth About Markets (Penguin) NIBRAS KAZIMI is a visiting fellow at the Hudson Institute, Washington LUCY KELLAWAY is a columnist for the FT JAMES LASDUN ’s second novel Seven Lies is published by Jonathan Cape NORMAN LEBRECHT is presenter of lebrecht.live on BBC Radio 3 BEN LEWIS presents BBC4’s Art Safari GEOFFREY MILLER is assistant professor of psychology, University of New Mexico PHILIP OLTERMANN coedited How I Write: The Secret Lives of Authors (Rizzoli, April) LEWIS PAGE is a writer. He is also a former naval officer and mine clearance diver NICK PEARCE is director of the IPPR JONATHAN POWER writes on foreign affairs for the International Herald Tribune MICHAEL PREST is a freelance writer specialising in business and economics ALEX RENTON won the 2006 Glenfiddich award for best food writer ROBERT SKIDELSKY is professor emeritus of political economy at Warwick University ED SMITH is captain of Middlesex county cricket club IAN STEWART is professor of mathematics at Warwick University BELLA THOMAS is programme director at the Ax:son Johnson Foundation, Sweden

COVER STORY

Left versus right defined the 20th century.What’s next?

24A hundred Prospect contributors responded to our question (some in the magazine, the rest on our website). The pessimism of their responses is striking: almost nobody expects the world to get better in the coming decades, and many think it will get much worse.

OPINIONS

14 House proud PETER BAZALGETTE Big Brother plays an important role in challenging stereotypes.

15 Liberal adoption RONALD DWORKIN We should let Catholics follow their beliefs over gay adoption.

16 Numbers games JOHN KAY A new bill proposes an independent ONS, but doesn’t mean what it says.

17 Illiberal lefts DAVID CLARK Nick Cohen seems not to know that much of the left has always been illiberal.

18 The nannyish state JIM HOLT Our “better selves” need some outside help in dealing with temptation.

19 Reasonable extremist BELLA THOMAS Ayaan Hirsi Ali is only an extremist to those who want to split the difference.

INTERVIEW

30 Pervez Musharraf JONATHAN POWER Pakistan’s president discusses the Kashmir dispute and backs the idea of buying up Afghanistan’s poppy crop.

ESSAYS

36 The poor bloody infantry LEWIS PAGE The lives of British soldiers are being sacrificed to save jobs in an inefficient domestic arms industry.

42 The future of proof IAN STEWART Does the use of computers mean the death of mathematical proof?

45 When the music stopped NORMAN LEBRECHT The culture of classical recording is dying as major labels slash outputs and the internet returns music, once more, to the ether.

50 Putin’s patrimony ROBERT SKIDELSKY Russia’s president has fused power and property. The consequences may be dire.

WITNESS

58 What happened to the Windies? ED SMITH The West Indies dominated cricket in the 1970s and 1980s, then fell into steep decline. What went wrong?

BRIEFING NOTES

64 Darfur—the crisis explained ALEX DE WAAL A guide to the war in Sudan’s Darfur region. Is it genocide?

4 Prospect MARCH 2007 www. prospect-magazine.co.uk

online ARTS AND BOOKS

VISIT OUR WEBSITE

COLUMNS

12 Speculations GEOFFREY MILLER The aliens have gone virtual.

22 Washington watch TUMBLER Dick Morris vs Hillary.

28 Rivers of Babylon NIBRAS KAZIMI Messianic Shia cults.

33 Lab report PHILIP BALL Climate change sceptics.

34 Matters of taste ALEX RENTON The best way to cook an oyster .

56 Brussels diary MANNEKEN PIS Barroso loses his bottle.

62 Inefficient markets MICHAEL PREST Murky benefits of the supercasino.

67 Letter from Argentina NICK PEARCE The corpse as political weapon.

88 Confessions LUCY KELLAWAY I’ve got a really juicy secret.

REGULARS

6 LETTERS 8 NEWS & CURIOSITIES 10 GRAYLING’S LITTLE QUESTION 10 ENIGMAS & PUZZLES 81 CLASSIFIEDS 86 THE GENERALIST 87 THE LIST

FICTION

69 The woman at the window JAMES LASDUN An Englishman in New York shows that chivalry is not dead.

REVIEWS 72 The art of conversation MARGARET DRABBLE considers a classic collection of Paris Review interviews, featuring Borges, Bellow and others.

74 A French force CHARLES GRANT Nicolas Sarkozy’s testimony lacks a political philosophy.

75 Raine’s sterile thunder TERRY EAGLETON TS Eliot’s greatness is beyond doubt—so why defend his politics?

77 Irony and genius PHILIP OLTERMANN What has made Daniel Kehlmann’s novel a giant bestseller in Germany?

ARTS COLUMNS

68 Widescreen MARK COUSINS Cinema isn’t dying.

79 Private view BEN LEWIS Great Gurskies.

80 Between the lines JASON COWLEY Zadie Smith and CAR Hills.

85 Smallscreen CHRISTOPHER HIRD Louie, me and hepatitis C.

FORTHCOMING DAVID GOLDBLATT

ON SPORT. MICK FEALTY ON IAN PAISLEY. HILARY MANTEL CONFESSES. INTERVIEWING KEN LIVINGSTONE. THE NEXT ISSUE OF PROSPECT IS PUBLISHED ON 29TH MARCH

www.prospect-magazine.co.uk

Archives every article from every issue of Prospect since October 1995. Subscriptions take out online or paper subscriptions; buy back issues, books and binders. Web exclusive read free, web-only content with weekly updates; plus daily blogs and discussion forums.

ONLINE ARCHIVE

Revisit our past coverage of some of the topics covered in this issue.

RUSSIA: ORLANDO FIGES on Russian identity, January 2001; ANTHONY ROBINSON on Russia’s petropolitics, February 2006.

CRICKET: MIHIR BOSE on India, race and cricket, August 2002; GEOFFREY WHEATCROFT on the death of English cricket, September 2005.

MUSIC: ERIK TARLOFF on Glenn Gould, July 2004; NICK CROWE on Britain’s thriving amateur music scene, July 2006.

PAKISTAN: PERVEZ HOODBHOY on Pakistan’s nukes, March 2004; PARAG KHANNA ’s return to Pakistan, September 2005.

WEB EXCLUSIVES

DAN KUPER starts his new career.

GEOFF DYER on the history of fashion photography. Plus log on to Prospect’s new Politico’s bookshop.

Prospect MARCH 2007 5