2 |

September 15 - 212010

News

TheTelegraph

μNews

PAGES2-13

μWorld News PAGES14-17

μComment PAGES18-21

μLetters

PAGE20

μObituaries PAGES22-23

μFeatures

PAGES24-26

μCulture

PAGE27

μExpat Life PAGES28-32

μBusiness

μClassified

μPuzzles

μSport

PAGES33-37

PAGE38

PAGE39

PAGES40-48

NEWS P12

NEWS P5

Royal cutbacks Prince reorganises businesses in face of financial difficulties

Playing the prize for laughs The judges say this year’s Man Booker shortlist is funniest ever

BUSINESS P33

WORLD NEWS P14

Iran nuclear threat NATO SecretaryGeneral calls for missile shield

Spreading the blame BP report points finger at Halliburton and Transocean

LOTTO 08/09

LOTTO 11/09

10 8 26 34 48 49 4 20 21 35 39 40

Bonus Ball 6

Bonus Ball 28

There was one winner of Wednesday’s £2.6m jackpot and two winners of Saturday’s £5.0m prize

μEDITORIAL OFFICE:111BuckinghamPalaceRoad, London SW1W0DT.Tel(Int 44) 2079312000.Emailweeklyt@telegraph.co.uk μADVERTISING:Fordetailsof local offices, contact Julie Bridge, Tel (44) 2079313290.Email julie.bridge@telegraph.co.uk. For further information from any advertiser in this issue, please email your contact details, the advertiser(s) and issue date toweeklytelegraphsubs@telegraph.co.uk μSUBSCRIPTIONS:WeeklyTelegraphSubscriptions, 3rd-4th Floor, Victory House, Meeting HouseLane, Chatham, KentME44TT. Tel (44) 1622335080.Fax(44)1634815163.(Office hours: 09.00-17.00 GMT.) Email weeklytelegraphsubs@telegraph.co.uk μDELIVERY INQUIRIES: Australia: Network Services. Contact MAGSHOP.Tel: 136116. Email magshop@magshop.com.au Canada: Vito Petrucci. Tel 0014165853131.Fax0014165855476.Email vpetrucci@globeandmail.com Denmark:Bjarne Balle-Christiansen. Tel 004532968600. Fax: 004532968682.Emailipd@ipddk.dk Germany:FrankBlumhofer. Tel 00496105925573. Fax 00496157804599.Emailfblumhofer@imd-delnet.de Hong Kong: Jeff Law. Tel 0085227568193.Fax0085227998840.Email Jefflaw@foreignpress.com.hk Kenya: Shadrack Ochanda. Tel 002542540280.Fax002542540295. Malaysia: Peter Lee. Tel (03) 79818563.Fax (03) 79819613. NewZealand:Netlink Subscriptions. Tel 006493082871. Philippines: Denis Catangay. Tel 8325383.Fax8313256.Email apcei@mnl.sequel.net Singapore: DoreenTan. Tel 62821960.Fax63823021.Email Doreen@carkitfe.com South Africa: Global News, 74First Road, Kew2090,SouthAfrica. Tel: (011) 8872670/1. Fax 0865117067. Email: andy@globalnews.co.za Thailand: KhunTai. Tel (02) 8873331.Fax (02) 8872259. United States: Marlon Johnson. Tel 18009332147. μNEWSSTAND INQUIRIES:ThePublisher, 111BuckinghamPalace Road, LondonSW1W0DT.Tel(44)(0)2079313447 ŠTheWeeklyTelegraph (USPS#006819) is published weekly for US$218 a year by Telegraph Media Group Ltd, 111 Buckingham Palace Road, London SW1W0DT, England. Periodicals postage paid at Newark, NJ. POSTMASTER:Sendall address changes to TheWeekly Telegraph, c/o SDSGlobal Logistics, 263Frelinghuysen Ave, Newark, NJ07114-1539.

μDATA PRIVACY: WhenyourespondtoTelegraphMediaGroupLimited’s competitions, offers or promotions, wemayuseyourinformation formarketing purposes. Wewill contact youbymail or telephone to let you knowaboutanyofourspecial offers, products and services whichmaybeofinterest to youunless youhaveasked us not to. Wewill only contact youbyemail, text message, or similar electronic meanswithyourpermission. Wewill only pass your nameontothird parties if you have consented for us to do so. In somecasesourspecial offers, products and services maybeprovided, onour behalf, byourpartners. If youhaveagreed to becontacted byus, your personal information maybepassedtoourpartners; however, in all such cases weremaina data controller of your personal information. Whenresponding to competitions, offers or promotions bypostcard, if youdonot wish for your details to beusedbyustosendyouspecial offers, please makethis clear by stating “NoOffers”. Werespect your data privacy. Youmaymodifyyourpreferences or get further information bywriting to us at Data Privacy, Telegraph CustomerService, Victory House,Meeting HouseLane,Chatham,KentME44TTorbyemailtodata. protection@telegraph.co.uk.

999

The Telegraph

T

Saints and sinners Our full MPs’ expenses database can be found online telegraph.co.uk/mpsexpenses

By Gordon Rayner Chief Reporter PHIL WOOLAS, the former immigration minister, could be thrown out of Parliament after being accused of breaking electoral law with a “toxic” dirty tricks campaign against a general election rival.

The Labour MPwas appearing at the High Court this week to face allegations that he told “devastating and far-reaching” lies about his Liberal Democrat opponent as he tried to cling on to his seat, which he won with a majority of just 103 votes.

MrWoolas is the first MP for 99 years to face a challenge to his election victory on the basis of publishing false statements about an opponent. If he loses the case, which is scheduled to last five days, he would face being disqualified by the court from sitting in the House of Commons.

MrWoolas denies the allegations made by Elwyn Watkins, the defeated Liberal Democrat candidate in the Oldham East and Saddleworth constituency.

The most damaging claim is that MrWoolas deliberately played on racial tensions in his constituency by falsely claiming that MrWatkins was “in league with extremist Muslims”.

His team allegedly hoped that by exploiting the racial divide in Oldham, the scene of race riots in 2001, they would “bring out the white Sun-reading vote”. The incendiary remark was made in an email allegedly written by Steven Green, MrWoolas’s campaign adviser, which is contained in court papers seen by The Telegraph.

The MP’s election agent, Joseph Fitzpatrick, allegedly sent an email in the run-up to the poll saying: “We need … to explain to the white community how the Asians

Phil Woolas celebrates retaining his seat in May. His Lib Dem opponent Elwyn Watkins alleges that false claims made in newspaper-style election leaflets, below, swung the vote in the former minister’s favour will take him [Woolas] out … If we don’t get the white vote angry he’s gone.”

MrWoolas is accused of fighting a “dirty and dishonest” campaign full of “lies, smears and totally false allegations”. MrWatkins’s lawyers argue in High Court papers that: “MrWoolas, believing that he was going to lose the election, resorted to terrifying white voters into believing that there was an extremist militant Muslim element in Oldham, who were in cahoots with MrWatkins. He wished to convey the message that a vote for Mr Watkins was a vote for extremists.”

Emails between members of MrWoolas’s campaign team, obtained by Mr Watkins’s lawyers, detail their alleged plans to claim falsely that MrWatkins supported Islamic extremists and was “prepared to condone death threats” against MrWoolas to secure their vote. Pamphlets sent out by MrWoolas also falsely suggested that Mr Watkins was receiving illegal funding from abroad and had lied about where he lived, it is claimed.

MrWoolas is accused of breaching the Representation of the People Act 1983, in which it is an offence to “make or publish any false statement of fact” about an opponent. MrWatkins’s legal

ANDREWSCHOFIELD/REXFEATURES

team claims that “MrWoolas exploited the privilege of free speech in order to demonise his opponent and to mislead the electorate … the false statements were devastating and far-reaching, and were made in an exceptionally marginal constituency”.

MrWoolas, the MP for Oldham East and Saddleworth since 1997, faced an uphill battle to cling on to his seat following disclosures about his expense claims by The Daily Telegraph last year.

He submitted receipts for items including tampons and women’s clothing, though he denied that he had claimed back money for the items on his expenses.

Continued from page 1

au pair. We all knew her because she used to hand out drinks at constituency social events.”

The Morris Chase report details an alleged “conspiracy” among Tories to undermine Mr Djanogly. The private detectives conclude: “There does not appear to be any current activity among the conspirators to revive the expenses allegations.

“This is because they do not have the time or resources to conduct investigations to trace the au pairs.” It added: “All four sources say that you have been damaged severely politically. Brown said, ‘Jonathan has lived to die another day.’” Their private report also alleged that another senior aide was too “scared” to speak out over “the whole inside story” of his expense claims.

Last week, Downing Street sources said Mr Djanogly’s actions “can’t be condoned”. The MP defended his actions because he wanted to identify the source of allegations in newspapers. In a statement referring to the private detectives, he said: “A report of their investigation was prepared and sent to me on a confidential basis and I am very disappointed to see the report released publicly without my consent. I would never have contemplated condoning anything unlawful and dishonest in the investigations, and the investigators have assured me that their inquiries were carried out in an entirely lawful manner.

“I am sorry if some people judge that I made a mistake. With hindsight I can see that I may have overreacted, but I was being subjected to very malicious, anonymous attacks on my family. I paid for the cost of the investigation myself and did not claim it back on parliamentary expenses.”

Morris Chase was in a controversy in 2007 when it was hired by a firm of lawyers for a civil case. It emerged that details of bank accounts had been obtained illicitly and provided to the client. Morris Chase said it had hired another company and had “not instructed” it to obtain the confidential data. The judge agreed that Morris Chase had not instructed anyone to obtain the information but concluded that it had “almost certainly” been obtained illegally.

Commons emergency debate over Coulson allegations, page 6